Journal of East China Normal University(Natural Sc ›› 2009, Vol. 2009 ›› Issue (3): 28-37.

• Article • Previous Articles     Next Articles

Comparison on analysis of 210Pb using alpha and gamma techniques

LIU Xuying, PAN Shaoming   

  1. Ministry of Education Key Laboratory of Coastal and Island Development,Nanjing University, Nanjing210093, China
  • Received:2008-11-06 Revised:2009-01-06 Online:2009-05-25 Published:2009-05-25
  • Contact: LIU Xuying

Abstract: Eleven groups of results on activities of 210Pb from IAEA(International Atomic Energy Agency)for international comparison were analyzed to discuss the difference between two methods for 210Pb analysis: alpha and gamma spectrometry techniques. Consistence of the results by two techniques was discussed through linear regression analysis; consistence of the results by the same technique among different laboratories was also discussed; their availabilities and utilization ratios were compared, and then factors that influenced consistence and availabilities were discussed. Results showed that, there was a good agreement and strong linear correlation in the average results using two different techniques; however, there was significant difference among laboratories even using the same technique. Relatively, availability of results using alpha technique was higher than that of gamma spectrometry technique, but laboratories using gamma techniques were increasing annually. Low activity of 210Pb would affect consistence among laboratories negatively, especially for gamma techniques. Therefore, it was suggested that laboratory quality controls should be enhanced and comparisons among international and national laboratories should be put in an important place in order to improve the analysis quality of 210Pb and comparability among laboratories.

Key words: gamma spectrometry technique, activity of 210Pb, alpha spectrometry technique, gamma spectrometry technique, activity of 210Pb

CLC Number: